How to prune garden trees for privacy AND light
The way you prune garden trees will make a big difference to your garden’s privacy and light.
Trees mask ugly views, and stop neighbours peering in. But they also shade your garden.
When garden designer Posy Gentles told me about a French technique called ‘transparent pruning’, or la taille de transparence, I wanted to know more.
By the way, if you’re interested in all aspects of your garden privacy, then see my book, The Complete Guide to Garden Privacy, currently available on Kindle and paperback in up to 13 countries.
Or if you want to read it on a tablet or pc, you can buy the Complete Guide to Garden Privacy as a pdf from here.
Trees create privacy
Even the most tree-loving gardeners cut down trees when they move to a new house. The tree, probably planted for a very good reason (sometimes only revealed when it is gone!), has usually got overgrown. Straggly, dense and too big for its boots, let alone your garden, it blocks out light.
When I first lived in South London there were hundreds of huge trees in the back gardens. Even in our tiny patch, it felt green and private.
As the area gentrified, gardens were re-designed for sun-loving plants. The trees vanished (in spite of their preservation orders). By the time we left London, we were all gazing into each other’s back windows.
And trees are expensive
A mature tree takes at least twenty years to grow. Some are best at thirty or forty years old. If you regret cutting down a forty year old tree, you must re-plant and wait thirty-plus years.
Or you could pay for a mature tree, in which case, you’ll be seeing a large dent in your bank balance. Think thousands – or even tens of thousands. (If you are thinking of buying a new tree for privacy, check out my 8 best perfect-for-privacy garden trees for affordable ideas.)
Why ‘transparent pruning’ could be the answer
‘Transparent pruning’ is a French technique masterminded by Dominique Cousin at Les Jardin des Vasterival in Normandy. You prune garden trees and shrubs by thinning out branches carefully. This allows light and air through, giving them shape and elegance.
Posy and I signed up for his one day course at Vasterival, even though it was in French. Posy renovates and restores gardens (many of them middle-sized). Reconciling over-grown, congested trees with the need for privacy is a major issue for many of her garden clients.
Vasterival is like the woodland gardens of Scotland and Surrey
Although Vasterival is far from ‘middle-sized’, it reminded me of woodland gardens in Surrey, and also of some conifer and rhododendron-based gardens in Scotland.
My parents’ garden in Camberley was three-quarters of an acre. It had an Edwardian planting style – rhododendrons, azaleas, camellias, privet and bamboo, with huge conifers towering over it. When the shrubs were in flower, it was magnificent.
Out of flowering season, it was a lawn surrounded by large, dark green lumps, under which even grass refused to grow. With such a heavy evergreen presence, it was hard to find the light for smaller shrubs, perennials and annuals.
However Vasterival, with its sweeping acres, has rich, green lawns under its ‘transparently pruned’ trees and shrubs. Dappled light comes through all day and there is the maximum chance of some overhead sun. The beautiful skeletons of the trees can be seen, and, all year round, other flowering plants grow at the trees’ feet or round their trunks.
My top ‘prune garden trees’ tip
Posy and I were able to learn to prune garden trees in French, because Dominique Cousin demonstrated while he spoke. My favourite tip was to avoid cutting branches short if a tree gets over-grown.
Even if you are not cutting your trees yourself and are getting a tree surgeon to do it, it’s worth making sure that they understand what you want. Many tree surgeons are brilliant with trees, but some are not interested in shape or style.
Find the bigger, older branches and cut them right back to the trunk, taking the whole branch out. If you cut a branch short, you just get alot of vigorous leaf activity and growth at the cutting point. The tree will become congested and your garden will be darker.
And prune garden trees to ‘lift your tree’s skirt’…
We noticed that many trees and shrubs at Vasterival were pruned to a skeleton at the bottom. Instead of foliage covering the lower branches, there were elegant ‘legs’. This, too, adds more light, creating space underneath where other plants can grow.
‘Lift its skirt’ was originally suggested to me several years ago by the talented illustrator and gardener, Hazel West-Sherring, when we were discussing what to do with a huge dark Leylandii in my garden which was usefully blocking a glaring street lamp. It was then a broad-based cone shape, but now we’ve cut off its lower branches, turning it into a lollipop. It is much less oppressive – while still performing its street-light blocking task.
How to train climbers up trees (so you can actually see them!)
I’ve often tried to train climbers up trees. The climbers disappear into the tree, then pop out in a great unreachable clump at the top. Then there is a fight to the death as to who will win – the climber or the tree.
‘Transparent pruning’ means that the base and lower branches of the tree are usually relatively clear. And the lighter canopy of leaves means that the plant can flower without having to get right to the top.
At Vasterival, Dominique Cousin trains hydrangeas, vines, clematis and many others into the trees. The climbers are pruned, too, so that their shape and their flowers can be seen – down at our level rather than high up in the air.
So if you’re thinking of cutting down a tree…
…try thinning its branches or lifting its skirt first. And don’t forget that there are lots of plants that flourish in shade. You don’t need brilliant sunshine all day to have year-round flowers. Once you’ve cut the tree down, there’s no going back.
And if we have another very hot, dry summer, then shade from trees makes a big difference to how good your garden looks. In the record-breaking drought and heatwave of 2022, lawns were greener where they were shaded for a few hours a day by trees. And the plants on shady side of my garden, protected by a row of trees, survived far better than those in my sunny border.
You can buy Dominique Cousin’s book, La Taille de Transparence (in French) on Amazon.
See this post to improve your pruning with more expert tips from Great Dixter in Sussex. Good pruning will make your garden look so much lighter and prettier.
There are other ways of pruning trees to make them work, especially in small gardens. Pleached, topiarised and multi-stemmed trees all look stylish and dramatic. Read Jamie Butterworth’s advice on trees for small gardens for inspiration.
Shop my favourite gardening books, products and tools
I’m often asked for recommendations so I’ve put together lists of the gardening books, products and tools I use myself on the Middlesized Garden Amazon store. For example, this is a list of essential tools I’d recommend any beginner gardener to start off with. Note that links to Amazon are affiliate which means I may get a small fee if you buy, but it doesn’t affect the price you pay. And I only recommend products I use myself.
And do share this using the buttons below – you could save a few (potentially) beautiful mature trees from being turned into firewood. Thank you!
Pin to remember how to prune garden trees for light and privacy
And do join us for a free weekly email with more gardening tips, ideas and inspiration.