Perennials made simple – how to choose and grow the best plants for your borders

May 29th, 2021
Posted In: Gardening know how

Perennials are the main flowering element of a successful mixed border.

So I went to one of the UK’s premier perennial plant nurseries, Hardy’s Cottage Garden Plants, to talk to Rosy Hardy about how to choose and grow perennials.

Festival of Flowers show border

Lupins (Band of Noble series), alliums ‘Mount Everest’ and Anchusa ‘Loddon Royal’ offer contrast in flower shapes in the Festival of Flowers show border at Hardy’s Cottage Garden plants.

Hardy’s Cottage Garden Plants have won 24 Gold Medals at the RHS Chelsea Flower Show over the years. They decided that Chelsea 2020 would be their last time at the show. So they designed a special border for it. However, the show was cancelled and this year RHS Chelsea was moved to September 2021, which affects the choice of plants.

So they decided to recreate the show border at their nursery in Hampshire.

Hardys show garden full of perennials

The show border originally designed for Hardys Cottage Garden Plants to exhibit at the RHS Chelsea Flower Show. 

What are perennials?

Rosy says that a perennial plant is one that continues to grow in the ground from one year to the next.

A ‘herbaceous perennial’ is a plant that dies back in winter and re-emerges the following spring.

Anchusa 'Loddon Royalist'

Anchusa “Loddon Royalist’ is a herbaceous perennial, which means that it dies back over winter, then re-emerges the following spring.

An evergreen perennial has foliage above ground all year round.

Iris 'Kent Pride'

Iris ‘Kent Pride’ is an evergreen perennial because it has leaves on it throughout the winter. Seen here with Lupin ‘The Governor’. They make a handsome pair.

Why are perennials important in our gardens?

Perennials are the mainstay of our flowering borders, Rosy says. There are perennials which flower in spring, summer and autumn – even a few flower in winter. You can get perennials of different heights, for shade and for sun.

So you can get a riot of colour for a long season with perennials. And because they come up year after year, they’re less work than plants which need to be planted, dead-headed, fed and then dug up again at the end of the season.

Lupins Band of Nobles series

The ‘Band of Nobles’ series of lupins. They add height and vivid colour to a border.

What is a hardy perennial?

‘A perennial grows, flowers, re-grows, flowers – it’s classified as a perennial as long as it lives for at least three years,’ says Rosy. A hardy perennial, therefore, is one that survives our winters.

A ‘half-hardy perennial’ is a perennial in its country of origin. They just can’t survive our winters, so we have to re-plant them every year. ‘In this country, we use a lot of half hardy annuals as bedding plants.’

Annuals are plants that grow, flower, set seed and die in one year. Their seeds come back but the plant does not.

Veronica 'Tissington White'

The small white flowers in the front are Veronica ‘Tissington White’. It’s a fully hardy perennial, because it will come back year after year in a UK garden and in US hardiness zones 3-8 That’s what makes perennials so useful in our borders.

Veronica Tissington White

A close-up of the Veronica ‘Tissington White’, common name Speedwell. It is such a pretty plant!

Perennial garden planting has had some exciting new directions over the past decade. One of the most interesting ones is naturalistic planting, which is beautiful and easy care.

If you cover your soil with mulch or landscape fabric, can plants grow back through it?

‘Some plants don’t like to have their crowns covered,’ explains Rosy. ‘So when you’re adding mushroom compost, garden compost or bark to your borders, leave a ring around where the plant head will grow through.’

Note that when you’re protecting tender plants over winter, such as dahlias, then you will need to cover the crown. I always add several spadefuls of compost. See more about dahlias in a UK winter here.

However, you shouldn’t use weed suppressant landscape fabric on borders with perennials. Rosy explained that weed suppressant fabric is made to cover up weeds and kill them. It’ll do the same for perennials.

Some people suggest cutting a hole in the fabric so that the perennials can grow up through it. But Rosy says that is only appropriate for shrubs, which stay where you planted them and don’t spread. Whereas perennials spread underground through a root system. Landscape fabric will stop that happening. Your perennials will die.

Hostas and phlox

A hosta and a low growing Phlox ‘Chattahoochee’. They’re hardy perennials and can spread underground, which is why you shouldn’t cover the surrounding earth with weed suppressant landscape fabric. However you could use a bark or other mulch.

When and how should you divide perennials?

Because perennials spread, they will need dividing every few years. Rosy says that a fast-growing perennial will probably need dividing every 2-3 years. Divide a more slow-growing one every 3-4 years.

‘You’ll know when some perennials need dividing, because the centre begins to die off,’ says Rosy. If you get a bald patch in the middle of your plant, then it’s time to dig it up.

It’s simple to divide a perennial. Dig it up. Then cut away the dead centre and split the plant. ‘Use a spade to cut it,’ advises Rosy.

You’ll see some people recommending that you use two forks back to back to separate the roots without cutting them. Personally I have yet to find anyone who has succeeded in this method. And Rosy says that it’s fine to cut the roots in places – ‘it gives them a root prune.’

Find out the honest truth about dividing perennials in this post here.

Which perennials bloom for the longest time?

Rosy recommends hardy geraniums, nepeta, geums and ‘herbaceous salvias’. Those are the ones that come back year after year, rather than the shrub salvias.

A shrub is a plant with a woody stem that stays above the ground all year round. Shrubs grow larger but they don’t spread.

Which perennials like shade?

‘Anything that’s stated as being a “woodland plant” will do well in shade, advises Rosy.

Hellebores, epimediums, pulmonaria, uvularia and maianthemum are all good for shade. ‘And hardy geraniums are my go-to plant,’ says Rosy. Several are good in shade, such as Geranium macrorrhizum, also seen here in this post about low maintenance plants.

Shady border

This is the shady end of the show border at Hardys Cottage Garden Plants. The large bronze-leafed plant is Rodgersia podophylla, partnered with ferns, maianthemum (false solomon’s seal) and hostas, which are both shade-tolerant perennials. The low-growing pink flowers at the front are Dianthus ‘Blushing Star’ which is happy in sun or part-shade. The edge of a shady border will usually be the sunniest part.

‘A lot of the shade-loving perennials are spring-flowering,’ says Rosy. ‘But most of them have really interesting leaf colour, which will give you good ground cover. ‘ Having good leaf coverage also helps deter weeds, as it deprives annual weed seeds of sunlight.

Which perennials grow best in pots?

Rosy says that all perennials will grow well in pots. But you must place the pot in the right place – sun-loving perennials need to be in pots in the sun and shade-loving ones in the shade.

‘You also need to make sure you get correct drainage, that you water only as much as the plant needs and the right amount of feed.’ If you can get those three right, you can grow any perennial you like in pots.

Which perennials are deer-resistant, rabbit-resistant or slug-resistant?

Rosy says that you can find lists of plants that are considered either deer-resistant, rabbit-resistant or slug-resistant, for example, on the RHS website. ‘However, you’ll always find someone who can tell you that a rabbit, deer or slug has eaten their plant.’

If deer are a problem, build a higher fence, she advises. Rabbits, too, are best deterred with a fence but make sure you use a wire with small holes. ‘Often people use a wire with larger holes that the rabbits can get through.’

As for slugs, she protects her young plants, such as hostas, with small amounts of organic slug pellets. But that’s only to protect the new, young shoots. Once the plant is larger, she says it will survive a few holes.

And Hardy’s Cottage Garden Plants is very wildlife-friendly. ‘We have birds, butterflies, newts, frogs, toads, voles, owls and more. They eat many of the slugs and snails.’

Which perennials are best for wildlife and pollinators?

‘Any of the flowers are good for pollinators,’ says Rosy. ‘It’s a myth that double-flowered flowers are no good for pollinators. Bees don’t like them because they like a nice flat platform and an open flower, but moths, butterflies, beetles and other pollinators are able to get into even quite elaborate double flowers to get the nectar and pollen.’

Go for as wide a variety of flowers as possible and try to have something flowering in every month of the year. That is the best way to support wildlife and pollinators.

Salvia caradonna Pink Inspiration

Salvia caradonna ‘Pink Inspiration’ flowers for a long season and offers pollen and nectar to a wide variety of pollinators.

How to partner plants and flowers when planning a border?

Rosy starts with ‘right plant, right place.’ That means making sure she knows which parts of the border are sunny, which are in shade and which in part-shade. She makes sure that she chooses the appropriate plant for the position. There’s more about how to choose plants for a shady border in this post here.

Then she likes to contrast big bold leaves with frothy, airy flowers. ‘Always tie in colour. If you have a bronze leaf, then maybe plant a plant with a bronze stem in front of it.’

She also partners different shapes of leaves. For example, a bronze Rodgersia and Hosta ‘Purple Heart.’

Contrasting leaves

Two contrasting big leaves – Rodgersia podophylla and Hosta ‘Purple Heart’ with a soft, frothy Phlox ‘Chattahoochee’.

Look at how the colours go together. ‘It can even be as intricate as looking into the centre of a flower, and picking up the colour at the centre, then repeating it in a different plant.’ For example, a verbascum with a red heart could be partner with a red flower.’

Geum 'totally tangerine'

The long-flowering Geum ‘Totally Tangerine’ works particularly well with the foliage colour of this peony.

Verbascum Copper Rose

This Verbascum ‘Copper Rose’ has a deep pink heart. You could pick that up and repeat it with a deep pink flower or even deep pink foliage.

Rosy also repeats plants or groups of plants, sometimes varying them. So the bronze-leafed Rodgersia is repeated along the border, but is partnered with a different shade of hosta.

Contrast leaf and flower shapes

Contrast leaf and flower shapes in your border.

‘And contrast flat flowers with round ones, add in spikes and big shapes – mix them all together.’


Aquilegia almost seem to float above the border because they have slender stems. Rosy says you can add layers into your border by using flowers like this.

There’s more advice on contrasting and placing perennials from head gardener and garden writer, Tom Brown, in How to Create a Stunning Garden Borders. And here are six perennials that flower for months on end, suggested by Doddington Place Gardens.

More about Hardy’s Cottage Garden Plants

There’s plant pairing and planting advice on the Hardy’s Cottage Garden Plants website, such as this post on planting with cool colours. And do read Rosy’s tips on how to choose the best plants for your border when you’re in the garden centre or nursery.

And you can find more perennial plant advice on the Rosy Hardy Gardening YouTube channel.  If you’d like to see a few more views of the border and to hear Rosy’s advice, then here is the video that partners this post:

Youtube video on choosing perennials

Shop my favourite gardening books, tools and products

I’m often asked for recommendations so I’ve put together the gardening tools, books and products I use myself in the Middlesized Garden Amazon store. For example, you can find the organically approved slug pellets I use on the Sustainable Gardening list.  Note that links to Amazon are affiliate, which means I may get a small fee if you buy but it doesn’t affect the price you pay. And I only mention products I use myself or which have been recommended by people I know.

And because people sometimes feel worried about gardening – that they may accidentally kill a plant by doing something wrong, I like to remind us all that ‘gardening is a question of trowel and error.’ Give it a go – and if something doesn’t work out, well, that happens even to professional gardeners. So I’ve teamed up with Teemill to create the Middlesized Garden Teemill store, which has a range of hoodies, t-shirts and tote bags, such as the ‘If at first you don’t succeed, plant, plant & plant again’ hoodie below.

Middlesized Garden teemill merchandise

Our niece Irene in the ‘If at first you don’t succeed, plant, plant & plant again’ hoodie. Also available as an organic cotton t-shirt and a tote bag.

Pin to remember perennials tips:

And do join us for a free once a week email with more gardening tips, ideas and inspiration.

2 comments on "Perennials made simple – how to choose and grow the best plants for your borders"

  1. Astrid says:

    I love gardening, I’m just learn y but I enjoy my time there.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

61 − = 58