What you really need to know about creating a roof garden…
This week I visited the roof garden at John Lewis in Oxford Street, designed by Tony Woods.
Tony is a former RHS Young Designer of the Year. He and his team, Garden Club London, specialise in urban gardens, roof gardens, pop-up gardens and living walls.
I asked him what we need to know in order to create a successful roof garden.
It’s not all about the weight…
The first thing that any of us think about when considering a roof terrace is ‘will the roof hold the weight?’
Unless you’re already living in a contemporary house with a purpose-built roof garden, Tony advises getting an architect or surveyor to establish what weight the roof can hold. And that doesn’t just mean the weight of pots, plants, soil and furniture.
‘People forget that you also have to include the weight of however many people will be on the roof at any one time. In the John Lewis garden, only a limited number of people can use the roof garden at any one time, because of the age of the building.’ (No wonder it feels so peaceful…)
But that’s not the only consideration…
There’s also planning permission…
You might think that if you have a flat roof, and you know it’s strong, then you can take chairs and pots out there. Voila! Roof garden.
But you have to have planning permission for a proper roof garden, which will probably also involve building controls. Amongst the issues they will want to consider are how you get onto the roof garden. Will you have to climb through a hatch? And how will you stop people falling off?
You’ll also need to consider how you get your roof garden building materials up onto the roof. ‘Luckily John Lewis had an old “carpet lift” from the days when people bought carpets in the store and took them away then and there,’ says Tony. ‘So we had a three metre high lift. Otherwise you’re restricted to whatever length or height of material that can go up the stairs or in the lift, unless you hire a crane.
Most of us do not have a useful carpet lift (carpet elevator, if you’re reading this in the United States). So remember access at the design stage!
Think about access to water…
Roof gardens are hot and exposed. Plants will need watering regularly, especially as they will be in pots.
‘If you’re having to struggle up a ladder and through a hatch with watering cans, watering will be difficult,’ warns Tony. ‘It’s really important to get a tap or irrigation system up on the roof for watering.’
You need to consider your neighbours’ privacy
A roof garden could be very invasive as far as your neighbours are concerned. Think about screens and where you’re going to look.
There weren’t many issues of privacy for John Lewis, because they are surrounded by shops and offices. But they did still need screening. Their neighbour to the left has a large neglected roof, with air conditioning units and other ugly detritus. ‘We put up a row of amelanchier trees and a hedge to screen that view,’ says Tony.
Tony created the John Lewis roof garden in 2013. ‘The London skyline has changed considerably since then. There’s lots of building, so although most of the hedging is fixed, we move pots around every year to block any ugly sight lines’.
Speaking of screening…
Screening is vital on a roof garden, because it helps reduce the windiness. But a trellis or a hedge is much better than a solid wall. Wind is broken up when it whistles through a hedge or trellis, but it goes up a solid wall then lands, still furious, on the other side.
Roof garden furniture – the important considerations
You might think that roof garden furniture should be super-light.
But light furniture can also blow away more easily. ‘You need to make sure that furniture is fixed down when you’re not using it,’ says Tony. ‘For example, some people put dead weights on the top of chairs and tables when they leave the roof.’
I blench at the thought of having to weight down garden furniture every time I leave a roof garden. Tony’s solution is to have garden furniture built in where possible.
And think about storage
‘People get excited about their roof gardens and buy 15-20 cushions,’ says Tony. ‘Then in bad weather, a bedroom becomes a dump because there’s nowhere to put them.’
This is another advantage of built-in roof garden furniture. Tony’s team design benches with internal plastic clip storage boxes, so cushions and other accessories can be stored in completely weather-safe conditions. ‘And they can’t be eaten by mice, either,’ he adds.
Roof garden pots
Like roof garden furniture, roof garden pots have conflicting issues of weight and stability. You probably don’t want to put lots of heavy pots on your roof garden, but if you put light ones they’re more likely to blow over (or away, if the winds are serious).
Tony’s first advice is ‘Don’t have lots of small pots. They dry out quickly and heat up, too. Go for large, sturdy pots.’ Sturdiness is about shape as much as anything – a tall pot or vase shape will blow over much more easily than a low or square shape.
Tony uses sheets of polystyrene or polystyrene balls in the pots to insulate them against wind and heat. It reduces the amount of compost you need to use, which also makes large planters less heavy. You can also buy ‘light compost’ for roof terraces.
Best plants for roof terraces
The best plants for roof gardens are those with small or narrow leaves, says Tony. Pines, for example, are good at withstanding exposed conditions and have needle-like leaves, so the wind will blow through them rather than blow them away. Low plants, too, are better than high ones.
What about accessories?
When Tony is called in to re-design a roof garden, he says he almost always ‘finds at least one smashed candle lantern lying on its side.’ Go for fitted lighting or lighting that’s easy to store. And if you have pretty displays, you need to find a way of securing them.
Flooring for a roof garden…
If your aim in having a roof garden is to feel closer to nature, then artificial turf may seem inappropriate. But a real lawn wouldn’t be viable. Decking or artificial turf add a layer of insulation to any roof, so they are still ‘greener’ than having a plain flat roof.
The decking on the John Lewis roof garden is a composite decking called Millboard. ‘Wood decking doesn’t always wear well,’ says Tony. ‘It gets slippery with algae in winter, and splintery in summer.’ Millboard is a wood-free composite that is moulded from real wood patterns.
Once again, if you’re concerned about a green space being environmentally friendly, Millboard have had their carbon footprint verified by an independent body. They say it is about the same as a cup of latte.
So why have a roof garden?
I asked Tony what he was most proud of in the John Lewis roof terrace design.
‘I love people’s reactions – their surprise – when they first step into it. It’s a total escape from Oxford Street and the busy city.’ It is a genuine garden – although the themes are tweaked every year and pots are moved around – the hedges and trees have matured.
Roof gardens are also environmentally positive, because they help reduce the heat given off by roof materials. When it rains, planters and plants absorb rain, thus reducing run-off.
The wildlife have enjoyed the garden: ‘We’ve even had a pair of ducks trying to nest here, presumably to get away from the crowds in Hyde Park,’ says Tony. This year, there’s a greater emphasis on native plants and wildlife-friendly planting to evoke an English country garden.
Rooftops are great for growing fruit and veg…
Roof gardens are usually sunnier than ground-level gardens, especially in cities (unless you’re surrounded by taller buildings that throw shade over your garden). So roof gardens are a great place to grow sun-loving plants like tomatoes, aubergines and herbs.
For more ideas about roof gardens, see Tony’s book for the RHS (with Kay Maguire) Big Ideas, Small Spaces – 30 Creative Ideas for Balconies, Roof Gardens, Windowsills and Terraces. (Note: affiliate link, so if you buy through it, I may get a small fee)
The John Lewis Rooftop Garden is open from April to September (check website for specific dates and times). There are a variety of activities and workshops as well as the cafe/pub/restaurant.
And if you’d like inspiration from other gardens straight to your inbox every Sunday morning, then do enter your email at the top right of this page. Thank you!